-
Website
http://immoralmatriarch.com/ -
Original page
http://immoralmatriarch.com/commenting-101/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
amlove0
6 comments · 1 points
-
Ardy22
2 comments · 1 points
-
María | Blissed
692 comments · 3 points
-
vdhrbh
8 comments · 1 points
-
Rachael1013
6 comments · 1 points
-
-
Popular Threads
(Sorry, I couldn't resist :p )
Excellent work here, Maria. I'm guilty of talking about myself too much in comments (oh crap, there I went again.)
I liked #2. When someone makes a comment about nothing, it's really hard to reply to it.
The latest from Ginny...Why You Are NOT as Awesome as Bruce Dickinson
I hate when bloggers reply to a few commenters but ignore everyone else - makes me feel like it was a waste of my time to comment. Either reply to everyone in the comments, or reply to some people privately, or don't do it at all.
I reply to every comment I get, with very few exceptions.
With regards to subscribing to comments: If you use Gmail, all of your replies will be in one email thread, and you have virtually an unlimited amount of space, so getting more email won't hurt you. If someone has a comment subscription, you should do it!
That's my stance and I'm sticking to it!
The latest from Avitable...Where did you put your wallet?
#9 almost killed me. Dyslexic or blind? BWAHAHAHAHA! I couldn't have said it better if I tried. And ditto on the Catchattica or whatever the hell it is. I'll never have it, either.
The latest from Mr Lady...Personally, I Don’t Even See a Glass
Another great post in your little 101 series - I agree with everything you said. I HATE those automated responses to comments. I still reply to every comment I get (if the person provides an e-mail address), but my blog is still small and I totally have time to do that and don't mind if someone e-mails me back at this point.
The latest from Rachael...Wordless Wednesday: My Blessings Abound
Thanks for addressing this. I am most definitely guilty of #5 from time to time, but I swear it isn't 'cause I'm all about me. I just have a tendency to go on and on when I read really good posts . . . um, like right now.
Bye.
The latest from LaskiGal...The Post About How Good I Look in a Swimsuit
great post. :)
The latest from Jobthingy...Fish Tales
The latest from Miss...For a good time call…
I can see your point, but to me, when it's appropriate, it's a good thing-- the comments make a blog a conversation instead of a speech, or at least a speech with a discussion afterwards. So the blogger talks about him- or herself, primarily, then finishes, and commenters take their turn and say, "Oh yeah that's great, I have a similar story or experience" etc.
And again, just like real life conversations, that's not always appropriate, and doing so excessively is tiresome and annoying, but by banning it, you're just asking for a world of blogs where people talk all about themselves and commenters show up to blandly praise them or parrot back whatever they said. I don't see the point. I like when people share their stories and thoughts based on whatever theme my post has set in their minds.
In rereading this, I realize that it sounds like I'm angrily ranting after being called out for something, but that's just the way I sound sometimes-- this is a great post, and a great series so far. It's nice to have all these things said out in the open by someone who feels free enough to do so.
You rule, and I'm sure when it comes to blogging, you must be right and I am wrong, because you do it much, much better than I do.
The latest from LiteralDan...A conversation with D-: Does not compute
The latest from Bluestreak...15 years in 10 bullet points
I, too hate CAPTCHA (I didn't even know thats what it was called 'til now)!
I am looking forward to the next installment!
The latest from cindy...The first tooth...
And you're right about comments in my opinion. I love seeing a comment from you because I know you actually read the post and felt the need to comment. You don't just drop comments for the hell of it.
The latest from dysfunctional mom...I'm Charmed with the Proximidade! Or something.
The latest from Jo Beaufoix...When I was 23…
The latest from Shania...We have confirmation...
The latest from Carolyn Online...What the eff word Ad Men?
I'm definitely of your same opinion and don't want to encourage a system of echo chambers by any means, which is why I don't delete comments, but there's sharing your personal opinion, a thought or experience that you had and there's writing a long, long comment, not necessarily focused on that opinion/thought/experience, but on you and yours.
I wish I was able to think of an example right now, but I can't.
And sometimes I just reply on the comment page because it's not important.
:)
But, people do things differently - take for instance Avitable [2nd comment on this post]. He has good reason for thinking you should reply to everyone on the page and if you're only going to respond to certain people, do it privately.
Your situation sounds a little like the one I had when I was on blogger, the one that made me give up replying to everyone - that damn noreply@blogger, and when I really had nothing else to say to some comments but something to say to others. You have to trust your gut. :)
#3...wow.Yes.Amen.In the past,I had 2 very regular "readers" who did that all the time. It's funny though when people ask a stupid question in a comment that makes it extremely obvious they did not read the post,otherwise they wouldn't have had to ask the question.Bugs the shit out of me...
Sharing this in my Google Reader cuz I know damn well there's people out there who need to read this.
For all you other commenters out there can I tell you how difficult the word verifications are on someone who has dyslexia? It is evil. TAKE THEM OFF!!!!!
Love your list, Maria. I completely agree with all of it. Again.
The latest from Kat...Absent
All excellent advice, Maria.
The latest from April...Ex Communication
I have to admit I'm guilty of #5 pretty often. Usually on Sundry's blog. She brings out some sort of insane confessional nature in me.
The latest from Maria...quite contrary
And Captchkawhositwhatever just makes me feel stupid every. damn. time.
The latest from maggie, dammit...up for air
There are certain bloggers who shall remain nameless, that come to my blog once or twice a month. It's on a pretty regular schedule so that tells me they are just going down their blogroll. I appreciate the readers like YOU much more. You aren't commenting so I come back to your blog, you are commenting because you are part of MY community and you like me. Or at least you are pretty good at making it look that way. :)
Oh look, I just talked about myself. Oops.
And CAPTCHA needs to just go away. I use Akismet only (well, I used to, I need to reinstate it) for comment moderation and I am proud to say I have only deleted one comment, EVER and it was also by a real life friend. Erm, ex boyfriend and he was aware of why I did it. heh.
Oops, talked about myself again, but at least you know I read your entry ;)
I agree 100 and 10 percent w/each any everyone one of them Maria.
Back in the day, aka before Blogher, I used to comment back on nearly all of my comments (Not to gain readers) but to really be friendly with the community. I found a lot of awesome people this way. Honestly, I did.
And now. I think I found a solution. I have my top commenters on the bottom of my blog. I check in about twice a week with all of them. I scroll through their posts from the week and comment on the ones that really interest me.
I really like that it is working for me. I still feel connected to my readers.
The latest from OHmommy...To my daughter, on her 18 month birthday, 32 days late
The latest from Tara R....Random Wednesday ~ listening
(and I'm going to say FUCK because you said I can)
The latest from Lynette...Psht...Mahna Mahna
If I stumble upon your blog via a comment, I'll bookmark it and read it till I feel overwhelmed and need to make cut-backs on my reads. It's a sad fact of blogging, but true!
The latest from tracey...A hole in the head's better than a hole in your coffee cup
The latest from Renée aka Mekhismom...Do Something
I wax and wane on replying to comments, sometimes I do if they ask something or if I have an update, but I don't expect they are read so I should really just email back. Hmm, yes I think I should!
Love the new sidebar you, super cute and a steal at $2!
The latest from Molly...Negative Nancy
Replying to comments is such a huge issue for people. I reply in my comments section, but not to everyone. It's not because I'm a bitch or I'm rude or that I don't care about every comment, it's just that sometimes I don't have a response to a particular comment.
It's a no-win situation.
Great tips, Maria!
http://www.u-g-h.com/wordpress-plugins/wordpres...
You've also prompted me to figure out how to get an about me page for my blogger ... assuming that school and Coco let up enough for me to post there regularly.
Thanks for the talking too. Will rethink things.
Oh and I couldn't agree more about that damn Captcha.
The latest from Mrs. Kitty...Good to know
I fully agree on each pther point as well. I promise I did not skim ;)
The latest from Angella...Let The Chips Fall Where They May
The latest from amy...Being Thankful
Personally, I try to be sincere in my commenting. I think even if I am explaining my situation a little sometimes (in the right context), my heart is in the right place. I figure the blogger will know that. Hopefully.
The latest from Mandy...I Have a Confession to Make
The latest from Miss Grace...Eh, announcement I guess
I hate word verification but found that I had no choice when I started to get those auto comment things.
The latest from sky girl...Thoughts on having a boy.
Good point though. Why bother blogging if you don't get to actually read anything and spend all your time jumping from blog to blog "spreading your seed"?
P.S. I'm copying you and getting an RSS Dolly of my own!
The latest from Jill...For tennis lovers only...
The latest from Meg...Toronto Story Part I
I have to say though, I do like it when the comment section turns into a conversation between the author and the different visitors- that's a big part of the enjoyment of reading (and commenting) for me.
The latest from Margie...When's your baby due?
Great post.
The latest from Siobhan...Word of the Week
Then I would just do what I always do, end up writing a novel about myself in a comment .... but this would be on my own bloody blog!!! :)
The latest from Karen MEG...Weekly Winners # 35: Hanging Around
The latest from BusyDad...They Should Slap a Warning Label on this Band
The latest from Elaine...It's A Moo Point....
The latest from Ashley...Different Shades Of Green …I mean, “Morning Sickness”
You're just awesome. :)
The latest from Sybil Law...Blow Jobs for Duke Employees
Bwaaaa haaaa haaaaaa! I couldn't resist.
I delete that shit every single time. I even do it with a shout of 'deleted bwaaaa haaaaahaaaaaa!'
Cause I am freaky.
The latest from Kelley...That kid will go far in life…
Thanks for the tip on blocking IP addresses. Very clever.
OH, and I love your new Avatar up there on the right. She does balance out the middle finger girl. ;)
The latest from JCK...Tina Fey saves my ass this week
I HATE when people do the 'thanks for stopping by my blog' comments. I want to hit them...with something big and heavy.
The latest from Employee No. 3699...Girls' Weekend Update
Great list, though!
I´m not gonna leave a comment on something that didn´t strike my attention,or something that I haven´t read, just to squeeze a comment in. Period. It just seems like bad Karma and I wouldn´t want anyone to skim through what I read and leave a comment for that reason, cause I put a lot of heart and soul into what I write (sometimes, sometimes it´s just crappy rants). And I´m certainly not gonna stop reading someone´s blog that is awesome just because they never reciprocate or respond to my comment. Then the only one that loses is ME.
There are others though, that I stop reading, cause they never reciprocate or even recognize one of my comments, and they just aren´t THAT GREAT anyway. Mainly, I didn´t have a community connection with them which is important for me in blogging, although sometimes people are so damn good that just their posts are all the connection I need and I don´t need any love back, they´ve given enough.
The latest from Bluestreak...Echinacea? Is that what I need to be taking?
I get loads of traffic but hardly any comments. I've taken it personally for the longest time and ya know what, it takes too much energy to fret about it the way I do...
However, I do have to admit to being one of those who will visit a site and leave comments time after time - well on posts where I think I have something to add to the conversation - and get kind of tired of never seeing a visit from said blogger. Again, it's probably their issue and not mine. Or, it could very well be that they think my blog sucks ass...which is fine. But I'd be a lying pig if I said it didn't get on my tits from time to time.
Awww, that was refreshing, confession without having to go to church!
The latest from Auds at Barking Mad...Going Green, One Pet at a Time
I have one more piece of advice to share about commenting. If you really want comments you can always provide your own. I quite enjoy ripping myself a new one under the moniker Charles Whackman, who is my imaginary evil twin.
It's a little insane, but it's fun.
The latest from Richard Whackman...BEAVIS FOR CEO!
I can never get the CAPTCHA crap right either.
The latest from Scylla...Ahoy! ‘n Happy National Natterin’ like a Pirate Day!
The latest from Peter Parkour...Header Restoration: Phase Three: Painting
i am loving this post series. loving!
The latest from ali...who needs a pet?! it seems we already have one…